When Is a Transfer Impact Assessment Required?
With businesses operating across borders, the transfer of personal data has become an everyday necessity—but also a regulatory challenge. However, under the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), such transfers are subject to strict regulations to ensure the protection of individuals’ privacy rights. A key component of these regulations is the Transfer Impact Assessment (TIA). Understanding when a TIA is required is essential for maintaining compliance and safeguarding personal data.
Understanding Transfer Impact Assessments
A Transfer Impact Assessment is a process that evaluates the potential risks associated with transferring personal data from the European Economic Area (EEA) to countries outside the EEA, known as third countries. The primary goal of a TIA is to ensure that the transferred data will receive an adequate level of protection in the recipient country, comparable to the standards set by the GDPR.
Key objectives of a TIA
Assess Legal Protections: Determine whether the third country’s legal framework provides sufficient safeguards for personal data.
Evaluate Practical Implications: Consider how local practices and enforcement mechanisms might impact data protection.
Identify Supplementary Measures: If gaps are identified, ascertain additional measures to protect the data effectively.
Related Feature: Risk Management – Identify and mitigate risks associated with international data transfers.
Scenarios Requiring a Transfer Impact Assessment
Not all data transfers necessitate a TIA. Specific circumstances dictate when this assessment becomes mandatory.
Transfers to third countries without adequacy decisions
The European Commission can determine that a non-EEA country offers data protection standards equivalent to the GDPR, granting it an adequacy decision. Transfers to such countries do not require a TIA. However, when transferring data to countries lacking this recognition, organizations must conduct a TIA to ensure adequate data protection measures are in place.
Identifying adequate and non-adequate countries
Adequate Countries: Examples include Andorra, Argentina, Canada (commercial organizations), Japan, New Zealand, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom.
Non-Adequate Countries: Countries not listed by the European Commission as providing adequate protection, such as the United States (outside of specific frameworks), India, and China.
Related Feature: Privacy Management – Document, track, and manage data transfer assessments efficiently.
Utilizing Standard Contractual Clauses (SCCs) or Binding Corporate Rules (BCRs)
In the absence of an adequacy decision, organizations often rely on mechanisms like Standard Contractual Clauses (SCCs) or Binding Corporate Rules (BCRs) to legitimize data transfers. However, the “Schrems II” ruling emphasized that relying solely on SCCs or BCRs is insufficient. A thorough TIA is required to assess the effectiveness of these safeguards in the context of the specific transfer and the legal environment of the recipient country.
Steps to conducting a TIA with SCCs or BCRs
Analyze the Transfer Details: Understand the nature of the data, purpose of the transfer, and entities involved.
Examine the Recipient Country’s Legal Framework: Assess laws related to data protection and potential government access to data.
Determine the Sufficiency of SCCs or BCRs: Evaluate whether these tools adequately address identified risks.
Implement Supplementary Measures: If necessary, apply additional technical, contractual, or organizational measures to bolster data protection.
Try RESPONSUM for free
Set up your personalized environment and see how RESPONSUM’s powerful features simplify your compliance workflows. Our experts are here to guide you every step of the way.
Onward transfers to additional third countries
When personal data is transferred from one third country to another, known as onward transfers, the original data exporter remains responsible for ensuring data protection. A TIA must be conducted to evaluate the risks associated with each subsequent transfer, ensuring that data protection standards are consistently upheld throughout the data’s journey.
Considerations for onward transfers
Chain of Responsibility: Ensure all parties involved in the data transfer chain are aware of and comply with data protection obligations.
Contractual Obligations: Incorporate specific clauses that mandate data protection standards for onward transfers.
Continuous Monitoring: Regularly review and assess the data protection measures of all entities involved in processing the data.
Related Feature: Vendor Management – Ensure third-party processors comply with data protection regulations.
Exceptions to the requirement of a TIA
While TIAs are crucial for many data transfers, certain exceptions exist where they may not be necessary.
Transfers based on derogations
The GDPR outlines specific situations, known as derogations, where data transfers can occur without an adequacy decision or appropriate safeguards. These include scenarios where the data subject has explicitly consented to the transfer after being informed of potential risks, or when the transfer is necessary for the performance of a contract between the data subject and the controller. In such cases, while a full TIA may not be required, organizations should still document the basis for the transfer and ensure that data subjects are adequately informed.
Common derogations include
Explicit Consent: The individual has given clear consent after being informed of the risks.
Contractual Necessity: The transfer is necessary to fulfill a contract with the individual.
Public Interest: The transfer is necessary for important reasons of public interest.
Related Feature: Data Subject Requests (DSARs) – Manage data access and consent-related requests effectively.
Transfers to countries with adequacy decisions
As previously mentioned, when transferring data to countries that the European Commission has recognized as providing adequate data protection, a TIA is not required. However, organizations must ensure that the adequacy decision remains valid and that no significant changes have occurred in the recipient country’s data protection landscape.
Book a demo to see RESPONSUM in action
Book your free demo and discover how RESPONSUM fits your needs. Get expert insights, a live platform walkthrough, and personalized tips to boost your compliance strategy.
Ensuring GDPR compliance with Transfer Impact Assessments
Conducting a Transfer Impact Assessment is a critical step in ensuring GDPR compliance when transferring personal data to third countries. By thoroughly evaluating the legal and practical implications of data transfers, organizations can implement necessary safeguards to protect individuals’ privacy rights. With tools like Responsum, organizations can simplify and automate compliance efforts, ensuring smooth and legally sound data transfers.
Explore Responsum’s full suite of compliance tools:
Visit the platform overview to see how we can support your privacy management needs.
Liked reading this article? Spread the word!
Get the inside scoop on simplified privacy management
Get exclusive tips ‘n tricks straight to your inbox. Join +1,100 privacy professionals already subscribed and stay ahead of the game!
